A fire can cause devastating damage to your home or business, leaving you with significant financial losses. If you have fire insurance, you expect your insurance company to fully compensate you for your damages. Unfortunately, many policyholders find that their claims are underpaid—meaning the settlement offer is far lower than what is needed to rebuild and recover.
If your Mississippi fire damage claim has been underpaid, you do not have to accept the insurance company’s decision. Jonathan Barrett, a Mississippi Fire Insurance Claim Attorney, has spent decades fighting for policyholders who have been unfairly treated by their insurers. At Barrett Law, PLLC, we help fire victims challenge lowball settlements and hold insurance companies accountable for wrongful claim handling.
Why Do Fire Insurance Claims Get Underpaid?
Fire insurance companies often prioritize profits over policyholders. They may use various tactics to justify paying lessthan what you are owed, including:
1. Incorrect Damage Assessment
Insurance adjusters may undervalue the cost of repairs or ignore hidden damage, such as:
- Structural issues (weakened foundation, damaged support beams)
- Smoke and soot damage to walls, furniture, and HVAC systems
- Water damage from firefighting efforts
- Personal property losses (electronics, clothing, jewelry, business inventory)
2. Excluding Certain Losses from the Settlement
Insurance companies may wrongfully exclude some losses, such as:
- Code compliance upgrades (electrical, plumbing, or roofing repairs)
- Additional living expenses (temporary housing, meals, storage)
- Business interruption losses (lost revenue while rebuilding)
3. Misinterpreting Policy Terms
Some insurers misinterpret policy coverage to minimize payouts. They might:
- Claim that certain types of fire damage are not covered.
- Deny coverage due to alleged pre-existing conditions.
- Refuse to pay for partial losses, arguing the property is still habitable.
4. Pressuring Policyholders to Accept a Low Settlement
Many insurance companies delay claim payments to pressure policyholders into accepting a quick but low settlement. They know that homeowners and businesses need funds immediately to start repairs and replace belongings.
What Can You Do If Your Fire Insurance Claim Is Underpaid?
If you believe your fire damage claim was underpaid, you have legal options to challenge the insurance company’s decision.
Step 1: Request a Full Explanation of the Settlement
Your insurance company must explain how they calculated your payment. Ask for:
✔ A breakdown of how damages were assessed
✔ Copies of repair estimates used by the insurer
✔ The exact policy exclusions they claim apply
If their reasoning seems incomplete, misleading, or unfair, you may have a valid claim for insurance bad faith.
Step 2: Obtain an Independent Damage Estimate
Hiring a licensed contractor, public adjuster, or fire damage specialist can provide a realistic estimate of repair costs. If their assessment is higher than what the insurer offered, this is strong evidence of underpayment.
Step 3: Gather Additional Documentation
To strengthen your case, collect:
✔ Photographs of the damage before and after cleanup
✔ Receipts for repairs and temporary housing
✔ Inventory of lost personal property with replacement costs
✔ Statements from experts supporting your claim
Step 4: Consult a Fire Insurance Lawyer
If negotiations with your insurance company are not successful, it may be time to take legal action. A Mississippi fire damage attorney can:
✔ Review your policy and claim denial letter
✔ Negotiate a higher settlement on your behalf
✔ File a lawsuit for insurance bad faith, if necessary
At Barrett Law, PLLC, we fight to ensure policyholders receive the compensation they are rightfully owed.
Who Is Affected by Underpaid Fire Insurance Claims?
Underpaid claims affect both homeowners and business owners, leaving them struggling to recover after a fire.
Homeowners
Homeowners may be forced to:
✔ Pay out-of-pocket for repairs their policy should cover
✔ Live in unsafe conditions due to partial repairs
✔ Take on debt to rebuild their home
Business Owners
Business owners face:
✔ Financial losses due to delays in rebuilding
✔ Loss of customers and revenue while their business remains closed
✔ Legal battles over commercial policy exclusions
If your insurance company has failed to compensate you fairly, legal action may be necessary to force them to pay what they owe.
Mississippi Laws Protecting Fire Insurance Policyholders
Mississippi law requires insurance companies to handle claims fairly. Under Miss. Code Ann. § 83-5-45, insurers must act in good faith and avoid deceptive practices.
If an insurance company acts in bad faith by underpaying, delaying, or denying a claim without a valid reason, policyholders may be entitled to compensation, including:
✔ Full reimbursement of policy benefits
✔ Interest on delayed payments
✔ Attorney’s fees and court costs
✔ Punitive damages for egregious bad faith conduct
If your fire insurance company has wrongfully reduced your settlement, you may have a case for insurance bad faith litigation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Underpaid Fire Insurance Claims
What if my insurance company offers a settlement lower than my actual repair costs?
You do not have to accept the first offer. Get an independent estimate and challenge the settlement. If necessary, hire an attorney to negotiate for a fair amount.
How long do I have to dispute an underpaid fire insurance claim in Mississippi?
Mississippi’s statute of limitations for fire insurance claims varies, but typically, you have three years to file a lawsuit for breach of contract or bad faith.
What if my insurance adjuster underestimated the cost of rebuilding?
An independent contractor can provide a detailed estimate. If the adjuster’s report is inaccurate, you can dispute the settlement with supporting evidence.
Can I sue my insurance company for underpaying my fire damage claim?
Yes. If the insurer fails to honor your policy or engages in bad faith tactics, you can file a lawsuit to recover the full amount owed.
What damages can I recover in a fire insurance lawsuit?
You may recover:
✔ Unpaid policy benefits
✔ Interest on delayed payments
✔ Legal fees and court costs
✔ Punitive damages for bad faith conduct
Do I need an attorney to dispute my underpaid fire claim?
While you can dispute a claim on your own, insurance companies often ignore policyholders until legal action is taken. A fire insurance lawyer strengthens your case and forces the insurer to pay fairly.
Harmed in a Fire in Mississippi? Call Mississippi Fire Insurance Claim Attorney Jonathan Barrett 24/7/365 at (601) 790-1505 for Your FREE Consultation
If your fire damage claim has been underpaid, you have the right to challenge the insurance company’s decision. At Barrett Law, PLLC, we help homeowners and business owners fight unfair insurance practices and recover full compensation.
📞 Call (601) 790-1505 today for a FREE case evaluation. We serve clients across Mississippi, including Jackson, Gulfport, Southaven, Hattiesburg, Biloxi, Olive Branch, Tupelo, Meridian, Pearl, Madison, Greenville, Oxford, Clinton, Horn Lake, and Brandon.
Let us fight for your rightful compensation so you can rebuild your home, business, and future.