What If My Insurance Company Says My Fire Damage Is “Not Covered” Under My Policy?

,
What If My Insurance Company Says My Fire Damage Is “Not Covered” Under My Policy?

When a fire damages your home or business, you expect your insurance company to honor your policy and provide the compensation needed to rebuild. However, many Mississippi policyholders face claim denials with their insurers stating that the fire damage is “not covered”.

At Barrett Law, PLLC, we help Mississippi homeowners and business owners challenge wrongful denials and bad faith insurance practices. Jonathan Barrett, an experienced Mississippi fire insurance claim attorney, knows the tactics insurance companies use to avoid paying valid claims and fights to ensure policyholders receive the full compensation they deserve.

If your insurance company denied your fire damage claim, stating it is not covered, you may have legal options to challenge the decision and secure a payout.

Reasons Insurance Companies May Deny Fire Damage Claims as “Not Covered”

Insurance companies may deny fire damage claims for several reasons, including:

1. The Fire Was Allegedly Caused by Arson

One of the most common reasons insurers deny fire claims is by alleging arson. If they claim you or someone on your property intentionally started the fire, they may try to void your policy and refuse payment.

Your Legal Options:

  • Demand proof of arson and request the fire investigation report.

  • If the denial is unfounded, consult an attorney immediately.

  • Challenge unsupported accusations in court if necessary.

2. The Fire Damage Falls Under a Policy Exclusion

Most insurance policies include exclusions, which are specific scenarios where coverage does not apply. Common fire damage exclusions include:

  • Negligence (such as leaving a stove on).

  • Defective wiring (if pre-existing issues were not repaired).

  • Lack of maintenance (such as failing to clean out a fireplace chimney).

  • Vacant property exclusions (if the home was unoccupied for an extended period).

Your Legal Options:

  • Review your policy language carefully—insurance companies often misapply exclusions to deny claims.

  • Provide evidence showing that the fire was not caused by an excluded factor.

  • Seek legal representation to fight wrongful exclusions.

3. The Insurance Company Claims the Damage Is Not “Directly” from Fire

Some insurers argue that certain types of damage from a fire are not covered, such as:

  • Smoke damage (soot, odor, or residue).

  • Water damage from firefighting efforts.

  • Mold growth due to water exposure.

  • Structural damage caused by heat, not flames.

Your Legal Options:

  • Most fire policies cover all damage caused by the fire and its consequences—challenge unfair exclusions.

  • Provide contractor or restoration reports proving the fire directly caused the damage.

  • Request a full policy review to determine the insurer’s legal obligations.

4. Your Policy Has Lapsed or Was Canceled

If you missed premium payments or the insurance company canceled your policy, they may claim you were not insured at the time of the fire.

Your Legal Options:

  • Request written proof of cancellation and payment history to verify coverage status.

  • If your policy was wrongfully canceled, you may be able to reinstate it retroactively.

  • If you were not properly notified, you may have grounds for legal action.

5. The Insurance Company Disputes the Extent of the Damage

Some insurers acknowledge the fire but dispute:

  • How much damage was caused by the fire versus other factors.

  • Whether the building is repairable or a total loss.

  • How much it will cost to restore the property.

Your Legal Options:

  • Get independent contractor estimates to dispute low valuations.

  • Demand a detailed explanation of how the insurance adjuster calculated damages.

  • Hire a public adjuster or insurance claim attorney to negotiate a fair settlement.

What to Do If Your Insurance Company Says Your Fire Damage Isn’t Covered

1. Review Your Insurance Policy Carefully

  • Request a copy of your full policy (including exclusions and conditions).

  • Compare your policy’s language with the insurer’s denial reason.

  • Look for coverage loopholes your insurer may be ignoring.

2. Request a Detailed Denial Letter

  • Insurers must provide a written explanation of why your claim was denied.

  • The denial letter should include specific policy provisions the insurer is citing.

3. Gather Evidence to Dispute the Denial

  • Fire department reports proving the cause of the fire.

  • Photos and videos of the damage.

  • Repair estimates from licensed contractors.

  • Receipts for personal property losses.

4. Appeal the Denial with Your Insurance Company

  • Submit a formal appeal letter with supporting documents.

  • Request a reassessment of your claim based on new evidence.

  • Demand an explanation for any unfair exclusions.

5. File a Complaint with the Mississippi Insurance Department

If your insurer is acting in bad faith, you can:

  • File a formal complaint with the Mississippi Insurance Department.

  • Request an investigation into unfair claim practices.

6. Contact a Mississippi Fire Insurance Claim Attorney

If your insurer refuses to reconsider your claim, an attorney can:

  • Negotiate a fair settlement and challenge wrongful denials.

  • File a lawsuit for bad faith insurance practices.

  • Ensure you receive full compensation for fire damage.

At Barrett Law, PLLC, we fight for Mississippi homeowners and business owners who have been wrongfully denied insurance coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fire Insurance Claim Denials

Can my insurance company refuse to pay for smoke or water damage?
Most fire insurance policies cover smoke and water damage. If your insurer denies these damages, they may be acting in bad faith.

What if my insurer says my fire was caused by arson?
Insurers use arson accusations to avoid paying claims. If you are accused of arson, demand proof and consult an attorney immediately.

Can I challenge a fire insurance claim denial?
Yes. You have the right to appeal, provide additional evidence, and file a legal dispute if necessary.

Does Mississippi law protect homeowners from bad faith insurance denials?
Yes. Under Miss. Code Ann. § 83-5-45, insurers must handle claims in good faith. If they deny a valid claim, you may have grounds for a bad faith lawsuit.

What should I do if my insurance company won’t negotiate?
If your insurer refuses to negotiate or reconsider your claim, you may need a fire insurance attorney to file a lawsuit for full compensation.

Denied Fire Insurance Coverage? Call Mississippi Fire Insurance Claim Attorney Jonathan Barrett 24/7/365 at (601) 790-1505 for Your FREE Consultation

If your fire insurance claim has been denied, delayed, or undervalued, do not assume the insurer’s decision is final. Many insurance companies wrongfully deny claims to avoid paying full compensation.

At Barrett Law, PLLC, we fight for Mississippi homeowners and businesses to recover what they are owed.

📞 Call (601) 790-1505 for a FREE consultation—available 24/7/365. We represent clients across Jackson, Gulfport, Southaven, Hattiesburg, Biloxi, Oxford, Tupelo, Meridian, Pearl, Madison, Greenville, Oxford, Clinton, Horn Lake, and Brandon.

Let us handle your insurance dispute while you focus on recovery.

/by
You might also like
What if My Insurance Company Says My Fire Was Caused By Arson? What if My Insurance Company Says My Fire Was Caused By Arson?
What If My Insurance Company Says My Fire Damage Is “Not Covered” Under My Policy? What If My Insurance Company Says My Fire Damage Is “Not Covered” Under My Insurance Policy?