What Qualifies as Bad Faith by a Commercial Insurer in Mississippi?

When Mississippi business owners purchase commercial insurance, they do so with the expectation that their insurer will stand by them in times of loss—especially after catastrophic events such as fire, theft, or business interruption. However, what happens when your insurer doesn’t uphold their end of the bargain? What if they deny your claim without justification, delay payment for no good reason, or attempt to pay far less than your damages are worth?

These situations may be signs of bad faith insurance conduct, and Mississippi law allows businesses to fight back.

I’m Jonathan Barrett, a Mississippi fire insurance claim and commercial bad faith litigation attorney. At Barrett Law, PLLC, I help business owners across the state hold insurance companies accountable when they fail to honor their policies. If your business has suffered a loss and your insurance carrier is stonewalling you, this article explains your rights, the law, and the steps you can take to protect your interests.

Understanding Bad Faith Insurance Practices in Mississippi

When an insurance company acts dishonestly or unfairly during the claims process, that conduct may constitute “bad faith.” In Mississippi, insurance companies are required to treat their policyholders fairly and honestly when evaluating claims. Failing to do so may expose them to lawsuits—not only for the value of the claim itself, but also for additional penalties, including punitive damages.

What Is Bad Faith?

Bad faith occurs when an insurance company willfully or negligently mishandles a claim. It goes beyond simple mistakes. Instead, it refers to an insurer’s intentional refusal to pay a valid claim, unreasonable delay, or attempt to minimize payments for no legitimate reason.

Here are some common examples of bad faith in Mississippi commercial insurance claims:

Delaying claim investigations unnecessarily
Denying valid claims without explanation or cause
Failing to respond to communications in a timely manner
Undervaluing property damage or business interruption
Using biased experts or manipulated estimates
Accusing the business owner of fraud without evidence
Misrepresenting policy language or exclusions

Each of these tactics undermines the purpose of insurance coverage and may form the basis of a bad faith lawsuit.

Who Is Affected and Why It Matters

Bad faith insurance tactics affect all types of businesses across Mississippi—from small retail shops in Jackson to large industrial facilities in Gulfport. These delays and denials can be devastating for companies trying to rebuild after fires, tornadoes, vandalism, or other serious events.

Commercial property and business interruption insurance are designed to help businesses:

Replace or repair damaged buildings and equipment
Recover lost profits due to shutdowns
Continue payroll or rent payments during closures
Handle cleanup, code upgrades, or rebuild costs

When an insurer improperly refuses to pay, businesses are forced to make tough decisions—lay off workers, close temporarily, or even shut down permanently. That’s why Mississippi law provides strong protections to level the playing field.

At Barrett Law, we’ve seen firsthand how these delays and denials impact real businesses. We step in to hold insurers accountable and pursue full compensation on behalf of Mississippi business owners.

Legal Obligations & Statutes Governing Bad Faith in Mississippi

Mississippi law recognizes an insurer’s duty of good faith and fair dealing under both statutory and common law principles. This duty requires insurance carriers to promptly investigate, process, and pay legitimate claims. When they don’t, they may be liable for breach of contract and bad faith tort damages.

Mississippi Bad Faith Law

Under Mississippi common law, a bad faith claim can arise when the insurer:

Lacks an arguable reason to deny the claim, and
Acts with malice or gross negligence in denying or delaying payment.

This standard was outlined in the landmark Mississippi case State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Simpson, 477 So.2d 242 (Miss. 1985), where the court affirmed the right of insureds to pursue extra-contractual and punitive damages when insurers engage in egregious misconduct.

Statutory Support

Mississippi’s Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (Miss. Code § 83-5-301 et seq.) also prohibits specific unfair conduct, such as:

Misrepresenting policy provisions
Failing to adopt reasonable standards for claims investigation
Not attempting to settle claims where liability is clear
Compelling litigation through low offers
Delaying claim decisions unreasonably

Although the Act doesn’t provide a private right of action, its standards are often used to support common law bad faith claims.

What Damages Can Be Recovered?

When bad faith is proven, Mississippi law allows for:

Compensatory damages for the original claim
Punitive damages if the conduct was intentional or malicious
Emotional distress damages in some cases
Attorney’s fees and litigation costs

Common Tactics Used by Commercial Insurers to Avoid Paying Claims

Many Mississippi businesses are shocked to discover the ways insurers try to avoid paying. Here are some of the most common tactics we see:

Shifting blame to the policyholder – Claiming the business failed to maintain property or exaggerated the damage
Overusing exclusions – Misapplying vague policy language to deny coverage
Demanding unnecessary documentation – Creating a paperwork maze to frustrate claimants
Engaging biased adjusters – Using in-house or paid experts to minimize losses
Dragging out the process – Hoping delays will pressure businesses into accepting lowball settlements

These are not just inconvenient—they are potentially unlawful when done in bad faith.

Practical Tips and Actionable Advice for Mississippi Business Owners

If your insurer is using delay tactics or denying your commercial insurance claim without clear cause, here’s what you should do:

1. Document Everything

Keep copies of all communications, including emails, letters, and call logs. Take photos of the damage, maintain repair invoices, and keep records of lost income.

2. Request Written Explanations

If your claim is denied or delayed, ask for a written explanation. Mississippi law encourages transparency, and vague or generic denial letters may support a bad faith case.

3. Don’t Settle Too Quickly

Many businesses feel pressure to accept a partial payout just to move forward. This can waive your right to full compensation or litigation later. Consult with counsel before signing releases.

4. Review the Policy Language

Policies are often complex, and insurers rely on confusing terms to discourage claims. A Mississippi insurance litigation attorney can review your policy to determine if the denial is lawful.

5. Talk to a Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer

An experienced lawyer can evaluate your claim, determine whether bad faith occurred, and help you pursue additional compensation where warranted.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mississippi Bad Faith Commercial Insurance Claims

What is the difference between breach of contract and bad faith?
Breach of contract involves failing to fulfill the terms of the insurance policy. Bad faith goes a step further—it’s a separate tort that involves wrongful conduct such as intentional delays, denials without cause, or failure to investigate a claim properly.

Does every denied insurance claim mean bad faith?
Not necessarily. Insurers can deny claims if they have a legitimate, arguable reason. However, if they lack justification or act recklessly or maliciously, bad faith may be present.

Can I still sue if I accepted a partial settlement?
It depends on the language of the settlement. If you signed a release, it may limit further legal action. But in some cases, courts will review whether the settlement was obtained through misrepresentation or coercion.

What damages can I recover in a bad faith lawsuit in Mississippi?
You can pursue the full value of your claim, plus punitive damages, emotional distress, and attorney’s fees—particularly if the insurer’s conduct was intentional or grossly negligent.

Is there a time limit to file a bad faith lawsuit?
Yes. In Mississippi, the statute of limitations for breach of contract is typically three years, and bad faith claims may follow the same timeline. It’s important to speak with a lawyer as soon as problems arise.

What should I do if my business suffers a fire and the insurer is stalling?
Begin documenting all damages, gather financial records, and contact a fire insurance claim lawyer immediately. Insurers often delay hoping you will give up or settle for less.

Are punitive damages available in commercial bad faith claims?
Yes. Mississippi courts may award punitive damages when insurers act willfully or with gross disregard for your rights. These damages are meant to punish and deter misconduct.

Can a lawyer help speed up the insurance process?
Absolutely. In many cases, insurers act faster once legal counsel is involved. A well-drafted demand letter from a lawyer can shift the balance in your favor and help avoid litigation altogether.

Do I need to sue to get my claim paid?
Not always. Sometimes a strong legal demand is enough. But if the insurer refuses to act reasonably, a lawsuit may be necessary to protect your rights and pursue the compensation your business deserves.

What types of business claims are commonly denied in bad faith?
Fire losses, business interruption, water damage, theft, vandalism, and storm-related losses are frequently disputed. Insurers often allege policy violations or apply exclusions unfairly.

Have You or Your Business Suffered Business Interruption Losses and Damages in Mississippi?

Call Mississippi Business Interruption Insurance Claim Attorney Jonathan Barrett 24/7/365 at (601) 790-1505 for Your FREE Consultation

At Barrett Law, PLLC, we understand the challenges Mississippi businesses face when insurers refuse to cooperate after a loss. We aggressively pursue justice for our clients and hold insurance companies accountable for bad faith practices. Whether you’re dealing with delays, denials, or lowball offers, we’re here to help.

We proudly represent business owners throughout Mississippi, including the Mississippi Gulf Coast, Central, Southern and Northern Mississippi, and the cities of Jackson, Gulfport, Southaven, Hattiesburg, Biloxi, Olive Branch, Tupelo, Meridian, Pearl, Madison, Greenville, Oxford, Clinton, Horn Lake, and Brandon.

Posts